Rating Girl Scout Cookies

I N T R O D U C T I O N

Girl Scout Cookies. The treat we look forward to every year. But how can one really know how these delectable delicacies taste? This is our (totally not opinionated) ranking of the Girl Scout cookies, achieved through meticulous taste testing.

M E T H O D O L O G Y

1. We analyzed and researched each tasty crunch of this delectable delicacy.\

2. We organized which cookies each of us tasted and gave ratings to the ones we did taste.

   1. Since all cookies were covered, we gave ratings to each of them.

   2. The ratings were averaged and finalized.

3. We wrote this article using our research and delicate tongues.

C O O K I E S

1. Adventurefuls [2025]

2. Caramel DeLites (previously called Samoas) [2025]

3. Lemonades (previously lemon-ups) [2025]

4. Thin Mints [2025]

5. Trefoils [2025]

6. Peanut Butter Patties (previously tagalongs) [2025]

7. GS Smores [Discontinued]

8. Toast-Yays [2025]

9. Caramel Chocolate Chip [2025]

10. Raspberry Rally [Discontinued]

11. Peanut Butter Sandwiches (previously do-si-dos) [2025]

D E S C R I P T I O N O F E A C H C O O K I E

• Adventurefuls: Brownie-inspired cookies with caramel filling and chocolate drizzle.

• Caramel DeLites (formerly named Samoas): Donut-shaped cookies with caramel topping and chocolate drizzle with coconut finish

• Lemonades: crispy lemon flavored cookies

• Thin Mints: mint flavored cookies with crispy chocolate covering :)

• Toast-Yays: crispy cinnamon cookies with vanilla frosting

• Caramel Chocolate Chip: Crispy sea salt cookies with caramel and chocolate chips

• Peanut Butter Patties: peanut butter cookies coated in chocolate

• Peanut Butter Sandwiches: peanut butter sandwiched between two cookies

• Trefoils: girl scout shortbread

• GS Smores: Graham sandwich cookies with chocolate and marshmallow flavored filling

• Raspberry Rally: Thin, crispy cookies filled with raspberry filling

F I N A L R A N K I N G S

Through Shreeya’s profound experience as a girl scout, and Shanti’s profound experience eating girl scout cookies, we have culminated these final rankings, which will determine the BEST girl scout cookies to exist.

These rankings are in our opinion, so please take them with a grain of salt (or sugar - they are cookies):

In eleventh place: Peanut Butter Sandwiches (ranked a 4/10).

Our tenth favorite cookies were: Peanut Butter Patties (ranked 5/10).

In ninth: Caramel Chocolate Chips (ranked 6/10).

Our eighth favorite cookies were: Trefoils (ranked a 6.5/10).

In seventh: Lemonades (ranked 7/10)

In sixth: Raspberry Rally (ranked 8/10)

In fifth place: Thin Mints (ranked 8.5/10)

Our fourth favorites were: GS Smores (ranked 8.75/10)

In third: Toast-Yays (ranked 10/10)

The second-best girl scout cookies: Adventurefuls (ranked 9/10)

And finally, last but not least, the best girl scout cookies are: SAMOAS (10/10 WOULD RECOMMEND)

C O N C L U S I O N

So remember, next time you buy a box of girl scout cookies, be sure to pull out your phone and double-check our rankings - our opinion matters most!